Friday, 29 May 2009

MPA Meeting: Britains policing problem remains unsolved

Two months have passed since the G20 and the brutal police operation against protesters in the City of London. Yesterday the Metropolitan Police Authority (MPA) met for the second time since the operation to question Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson. At the first meeting the Met showed no signs of having taken on board the serious and widespread criticism of their actions and at times actively mis-represented what had taken place in an attempt to spin themselves out of trouble. So it was with a fair deal of scepticism that myself and Anna Bragga of Defend Peaceful Protest went down to City Hall to put our questions to the Met once again. This time we asked:


1. Why did the police forcibly advance at the South end of the Climate Camp at around 7pm without warning if it was simply a matter of needing a containment to “prevent disorderly protestors from the Bank of England from joining” and, in particular, why did a line of officers use force to advance on the right hand side when there was access from Great Helens?


2. Given the evidence of Police ID concealment or accidental obscurement at the G20 and subsequent demonstrations, will the Police Uniform review look into placing numbers on the back and front of uniforms and protective gear rather than the shoulder so that Police ID on future demonstrations is more clearly identifiable and less easily removed?


3. Given the evidence submitted to MPA members prior to this meeting about inconsistencies in police statements, how are we as members of the public, and the MPA members, to feel confident in the facts as presented in Metropolitan Police Briefings thus far?


4. Defend Peaceful Protest are aware of five separate bodies investigating aspects of the G20 protests: The Home Affairs Select Committee, the Joint Committee on Human Rights, the IPCC, Her Majesties Inspectorate of Constabulary and the Metropolitan Police Authority itself. What effort is being made to ensure that all bodies are working together to collect evidence from protestors in order to make an effective inquiry into protesting policing at the G20 possible?


These questions raise serious ethical and constitutional concerns and require straightforward answers from the police without spin if the lessons of the G20 are to be learnt and public faith in protest policing repaired. Unfortunately, it seems both the MPA chief executive and the Met have no interest in answering inconvenient questions until Her Majesties Inspectorate of Constabulary reports back on their enquiry next month. And the answer to question four suggests there has been no attempt to co-ordinate by the FIVE separate bodies investigating aspects of the G20 - hardly joined up government! A multitude of investigations with overlapping remits which are not sharing evidence is hardly conducive to the thorough and systematic investigation we need to ensure the mistakes committed on April 1st aren’t repeated.One small victory following the first meeting was the formation of a new civil liberties panel for the MPA. This will look specifically at aspects of policing which might infringe upon the rights of Londoners and those that protest within the city.


Although the setting up of this panel is good news since up until now no body has existed to look at the civil liberties impact of policing in London, Defend Peaceful Protest still have significant concerns as to what strength the panel will have in actually effecting change. This concern was echoed by Labour Assembly Member Joanne McCartney, Lib Dem Dee Doocey and Jenny Jones of the Greens who also questioned whether the panel would be adequately resourced to take on a proper investigation into the G20 policing which would be a huge job.


So it looks very likely the enquiry by the MPA is not going to provide proper answers for many protesters. We’ll wait and see for the report back from HMIC at the next meeting, but in all probability this will gloss over protesters’ concerns and conclude that police tactics, including the practice of aggressively kettling peaceful protesters, were justified.


If this is the way government holds the police to account it might explain the reason a number of protest groups and activists who were present at the G20 have not even engaged with the MPA or other enquiries: they’ve simply given up on what is a laborious and often fruitless process. It’s time we saw an end to the impunity that has built up amongst the police which permits them to get away with serious and persistent violations of civil liberties that damage the health of our democracy. In the meantime we’ll do our best to try and ensure these investigations at the very least hear the concerns protesters have with the current state of policing.

Thursday, 28 May 2009

A brief report on the UCAPV rally Sat 23rd May.

On Saturday at 3pm I went along to observe the police tactics deployed against the march and demonstration against police violence organised by group United Campaign Against Police Violence.

Two other DPP members joined me walking with the demo in order to film and observe the tactics of police. It’s worth noting that it was always going to be a tricky one for the police since this demonstration was specifically for those concerned about violent Police tactics! However given recent media coverage I didn’t really expect even the most aggressive police officer to step out of line and thankfully we didn’t see any repeats of the events at the G20.

The march began at Trafalgar Square, headed down past number 10 Downing Street and turned right at Parliament Square towards Scotland Yard. Here there were speeches and the march organisers planned a kettle of Scotland Yard. Police were in attendance along the whole route of the march and at Scotland Yard. The visible police presence was a mixture of Met Police in normal gear (not riot police), a sizeable group of FIT officers and a number of police vans no doubt with riot police in reserve.

The good news:
All police officers present appeared to be wearing ID, which was an improvement on the Bank of England Protests on the 1st and 2nd April where a number of examples of lack of ID were documented. A Silver Star commander was present and for me at least he was reasonably accessible to approach and communicate with. worth noting here that unfortunately there was no attempt at dialogue with the police by the UCAPV demonstration organisers prior to the beginning of the march, due to anger around the way some groups within the coalition have been treated in the past demonstrations (G20, Gaza and Bush demonstrations). There was also no attempt at kettling by the police, although in a turning of the tables demonstrators did briefly form a cordon around Scotland Yard as a symbolic act.

The bad news:
The only really poor element of policing of the demo happened at quite an important point when the relatives of those who had died in police custody were reading out a roll call of names. In a fairly provocative and unhelpful move the Police decided halfway through this they would start their own announcement ordering people to move from the road. Have interrupted one of the bereaved family members a number of demonstrators moved over to van and began remonstrating which then left the announcement entirely inaudible to most of the demonstration.

At this point (16.30pm) some officers began getting into protective gear and looked ready to impose a cordon. Despite being 10ft away from the Van I actually had to approach the police commander and asked what the announcement had said. Apparently it was to stop blocking the entrance to Scotland yard and the road outside or risk facing arrest under S14 of the Public Order act and for violation of ‘access and egress’.

Both of these of course are legitimate concerns but considering the demonstration had only been there a short amount of time, the way the announcement was made was not only inappropriate, interrupting a bereaved family member but also entirely inadequate in terms of informing the demonstrators. In addition the use of access and egress to Scotland yard as an excuse to move people on was on dodgy grounds since despite Silver Stars assertions that there was only one entrance to the building I checked and there was a totally unaffected second entrance around the corner…

Other than this confusion over announcements, individual police officers also proved to be pretty unhelpful in terms of any form of dialogue. Before managing to find the Silver Star commander I asked 3 other officers what the announcement had said and all declined to officer any explanation. For instance officer KD54 of the FIT team when approached and asked what the announcement had asked demonstrators to do simply refused to give me any information and walked way from me saying he did not wish to speak to me. Two other officers also acted in this way, one ignoring me entirely and the other saying he had not heard the announcement but not offering me any advice as to who to speak to. I then moved a little further away to the officers who had come through as back up and they had no knowledge of what the announcement stating ‘we were round the corner so didn’t hear it’ Although in the end the situation calmed down and the police did not appear to deploy excessive force to clear the road at the end of the demo.

I think this does give another example of the problem at climate camp: The police claim to have informed people the demo is being shut down yet the method of informing people is woefully inadequate. Not only in terms of the announcement but the fact that officers either refuse to explain it or don’t even hear it themselves. Combined as it was at the G20 with use of excessive force this lack of communication creates real problems. I appreciate its not always easy, but its vitally important that our front line police officers actually be educated that they need to be accessible to both the public and protestors, even if they disagree with the nature of the protest. In the case of the FIT officer mentioned above, there is no excuse since they are supposed to engage in dialogue with protestors as part of their job (although presently all they seem to do is film them).

Monday, 18 May 2009

Defend Peaceful Protest - Part1 video appendix to MP select committee written evidence

Full report to follow, but here is a useful video archive. Please add to it by posting your comments and video links below to both the G20 and any other subsequent demo's where you see police misbehaving:

Who guards the guardians?

APPENDIX 1
Section 1: Police ‘kettling’ operation at Climate Camp
(Location, European Carbon Exchange, Bishopsgate)

Section 2: Use of specialist squads
(Police Dogs at Bank of England and Taser Raids at locations in Whitechapel)

Section 3: Freedom of the press
(Location: Bank of England)

Section 4: Police concealment of ID
(Location: Various)

Section 5: Death of Ian Tomlinson
(Cornhill, near Bank of England Protest)

1. Police kettling operation at climate camp
From 1.37 minutes into this video you see the concerted attack on demonstrators by police as they attempt to clear part of the climate camp. Appx. 7.10pm on 1st April,

Riot Police deployed against peaceful protestors
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t244-zEENSs&feature=related
10.50pm Second climate camp charge
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sBNxIOfW5F4&feature=related

Attacks with repeated beating of riot shields on demonstrators – after 11pm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YR27Qehxw4w&feature=related

2. Use of specialist squads
Police Dogs
As police try to move protesters in the City of London on 1 April, a police dog bites a man who is turning away from officers.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovVLpwQjKVI&NR=1

This happened on Threadneedle Street outside the Stock Exchange building and Pavarotti's cafe. Four police officers with aggressive alsatian dogs were facing east, and this guy ran up to them. One of the dogs was brought forward by its handler and jumped up at him and bit his arm.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zGGf-Ev5a1E&feature=related

Taser raids
Police raid the day after April 1st 2009 G20 demo. Taser held (visible if paused at 24s) in entry to building and to threaten group of protestors sitting down holding hands in air. Police have since admitted using taser as threat weapon in this raid.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zP5I82I3n5E

Corroborating video ‘On April the 2nd the sleeping spaces where protesters were staying were raided. Many of them had been ‘kettled’ in on Bishopsgate until after the tube stopped the previous night, so had no-where else to stay the night. Note the second officer who enters at 0:49 is ARMED’

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmqdE0lXcxk&feature=related

Video showing build up to raid, over 100 riot police in attendance and about 20 FIT officers. No attempt made by police to respond to protestors attempts to negotiate.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYNrf2GIRO4

3. Freedom of the press
Met Officer warn press photographers that they will be arrested under S14 if they stay in the area. The force later apologised for using this measure on some journalists and photographers.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0-g01kwi1k&feature=related

Al Jazeera reporter is caught in a police charge at Bank of England.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HpcVDu1GPfI&feature=related

4. Deliberate concealment of ID by police officers
G20 Demo. Two videos in the Ian Tomlinson section [5] show officers not disclosing their ID numbers. Here are two further examples of officers directly asked for ID and refusing to give it.

Bank of England vigil, 2nd April
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1cieO-34Yc

Bank of England Kettle, 1st April
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7ysKLt3duo&NR=1 (34s)

Tamil Demo – ID concealment still occurring

Police continue to conceal ID at Tamil Demo – Friday 17th April, 16 days after G20 demonstrations and after Sir Paul Stephenson gave direct order to stop concealment of ID by police at demos.

Guardian Report:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/davehillblog/2009/apr/17/boris-g20-police-assault-ian-tomlinson3

Evening Standard: Photo evidence:
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standard/article-23677372-
details/Police+should+be+punished+for+covering+up+ID/article.do


5. Death of Ian Tomlinson & Assault on protestor at vigil next day

Ian Tomlinson Death – Initial Police Interview

The original police statement claims ‘the police came under sustained fire from missiles’. ‘paramedics came to help and they also came under fire’ The latter part of this video and subsequent videos in this section show actual events which totally contradict the original police version of events.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4OfBcg9xy0&feature=related

Obstruction of ambulance by Police
7.37pm, Corn Exchange. Police line obstructs ambulance – the original police press release about the incident claimed that demonstrators had been the ones blocking the ambulance reaching Ian Tomlinson. The police blocked the ambulance going to Ian Tomlinson for about 3 minutes.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6f0S6PPLI8Q&feature=related

Original Guardian footage of Ian Tomlinson assault by police officer
The Guardian obtained this footage of Ian Tomlinson at a G20 protest in London shortly before he died. It shows Tomlinson, who was not part of the demonstration, being assaulted from behind and pushed to the ground by baton-wielding police

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HECMVdl-9SQ&feature=related
Women assaulted at Ian Tomlinson Vigil

Thursday 2nd April – Nicola Fisher slapped and batoned by police officer at peaceful

Ian Tomlinson video, location: Bank of England
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V23PGWd46MM

Protest - A demonstrable need for it.

[UPDATE FROM MAY 14th DEFEND PEACEFUL PROTEST FACEBOOK GROUP]

So, the MP's expenses scandal has finally broken, despite attempts by some members of the House to make themselves exempt from Freedom of Information requests. It appears the banks aren't the only ones with loose morals, as several MP's today appear to have committed acts verging on fraud.

In other news, the Home Affairs select committee met on tuesday about the G20 protests. As you well know at the G20 as well as agreeing action on the credit crunch (and failing to agree much action on climate change) we saw brutal policing and suppression of demonstrators who wanted to voice their opinions legitmately on these issues.

Whilst some MP's at the committee were clearly concerned about heavy handed policing, others - such as David Davies and Keith Vaz - seemed more concerned about traffic disruption than people getting violently attacked... Quite frankly many of them did not appear to have done more than skim read the evidence submitted to the committee. Some were just totally out of touch - one MP even asked whether Chris Abbot, one of the victims of the violence giving evidence, had managed to get the police ID officer of a riot officer who punched him in the face.

As Chris said, its kind of hard to identify someone when your being punched and beaten with batons and shields by riot officers!

You can watch the full video here
http://www.parliamentlive.tv/main/Player.aspx?meetingId=4072
A guardian report summarising it here
www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/may/13/police-g20-protest

So in summary, we're not happy with the response by politicians yet. We're even less happy with the response by the police. So we'll be back to the MPA on Thursday 28th with more questions - they had better give us decent answers this time!

You can read our questions below. And here are two more upcoming events as you may want to attend.


DEMO
United Campaign Against Police Violence demonstration:
3pm Saturday 23 May UCAPV will march from Trafalgar Square to New Scotland Yard, via Downing Street.

Members Defend Peaceful Protest intend to be at the demo to observe the policing used and to protest about the attack on our democratic right to protest and the fundamental human rights violated.

MET POLICE AUTHORITY PUBLIC MEETING
Thursday 28th May 10am - 12pm at City Hall (betwen london bridge and blackfriars)

If you want to help us keep up the pressure on the police via political channels its really worth coming along to this. As you can see in question three we''re asking what the deal is with the blatant misinformation they included in their last report...


Questions as follows:

1. Why did the police forcibly advance at the South end of the Climate Camp at around 7pm without warning if it was simply a matter of needing a containment to “prevent disorderly protestors from the Bank of England from joining” and, in particular, why did a line of officers use force to advance on the right hand side when there was access from Great Helens.

2. Given the evidence of Poice ID concealment or accidental obscurement of ID at the G20 and subsequent demonstrations, will the Police Uniform review look into placing numbers on the back and front of uniforms and protective gear rather than the shoulder so that Police ID on future demonstrations is more clearly identifiable and less easily removed.

3. Given the evidence submitted to MPA members prior to this meeting about inconsistencies in police statements, how are we as members of the public, and the MPA members, to feel confident in the facts as presented in Metropolitan Police Briefings thus far?

4. Defend Peaceful Protest are aware of five seperate bodies investigating aspects of the G20 protests: The Home Affairs Select Committee, the Joint Committee on Human Rights, the IPCC, Her Majesties Inspectorate of Constabulary and the Metropolitan Police Authority itself. What effort is being made to ensure that all bodies are working together to collate evidence from protestors in order to make an effective inquiry into protesting policing at the G20 as possible.

Saturday, 11 April 2009

Website up!

WEBSITE UP!
http://www.killianthearchitect.com/no2policeviolence.html

Great work from our two volunteer web designers who got a site up in under 24 hours! You can see some actions to take and we will be putting up more content as time goes on. Its early days yet so we dont have our own domain but this is only the beginning!

At the moment we are a loose collection of volunteers from all walks of life who have been united by the shocking use of violence displayed at the G20 protests. If you feel the same and want to change our policing for the better, email us!

no2policeviolence@googlemail.com

Friday, 10 April 2009

Update on campaign

Hi all,

Meeting at 11am outside Bethnal Green tube, so the plan is as follows

- Distributing flyers
- Spreading the word and meeting like minded concerned people
- Monitoring the police behaviour and encouraging people to demonstrate in a non- violent manner and avoid confontation - which would be counter-productive
- Providing a basic information pack on the objectives of the group and briefing media, political groups and other pressure groups who are interested in affliliating or undertaking their own activities and support our goals

On the subject of our goals and who we are:

We are a grassroots movement of ordinary people, with views across the political spectrum who are united by one common purpose - to protest our rights and fundamental freedom.

We want to be able to express our concerns and the medium of protest when constructively done is a legitimate way for people to air their greivances. It should not be suppressed in the way it was last week in a parliamentary democracy.

OUR AIMS

- LONG TERM REFORM – Reform of police tactics deployed and the overall management of the G20 operation. New guidelines based on police role to support and facilitate peaceful protest.

- JUSTICE - Independent investigation of all alleged assaults by individual police officers.

- INVESTIGATE IAN’S DEATH - Criminal investigation into the death of bystander Ian Tomlinson and his assault by police officers on Wednesday 1st April 2009.

- KETTLING BANNED - A ban on the use of the kettling technique against non-violent protestors. Legal recognition that used against peaceful protestors, this violates article 5 and 13 of the human rights act.

Your civil liberties are under attack, stand up for them!

Legal ruling and opinion on kettling from an expert

Here i've posted from a source I contacted about G20's who was able to offer me an opinion on the police tactics and in particular the police approach of 'kettling'.

To add my laymans opinion:

For those that are unfamiliar with the term, Kettling is throwing up a police cordon and not allowing anyone within an arbitarily defined legal area to leave. In the recent G20 protests this was used against peaceful demonstrations, which did not have a reasonable chance of violence apparent to me or the many other impartial observers who have talked about it elsewhere.

Whats more, the 'Kettling' of protestors was exacerbated by the use of riot police and deliberate squeezing of the space available to protestors after the police cordon had been created. There were also acts of violence by the police, batoning and hitting with the fronts and sharp edges of shields in order to squeeze in the kettle. How can this be termed disproportionate force against peaceful protest?


The legal researcher I contacted (must remain anonymous) explained the following:

LEGAL OPINION

On the question whether the police tactics, and in particular the use of kettling, are legal - as you rightly say it is a question that has come up before, and reached the House of Lords in the case of Austin, which was decided earlier this year, and - again, as you say - is now going to Strasbourg. We have not done any susbtantive analysis of the issues raised in that case to see what we would think about them, or whether we would agree with the decision of the Lords. But in case it's of interest to you...

...I would also think that, even on the standard established in this judgment, there would be some ground for asking whether the use of kettling this week was, as Lord Hope said it had to be, "resorted to in good faith, [...] proportionate and [...] enforced for no longer than is reasonably necessary" - no doubt that will be an argument advanced by lawyers taking forward complaints from yesterday. Also worth noting the last paragraph that I pasted below - from Lord Neuberger's speech - again, I would think there is a good case to be made for saying that the cordon here was being used to punish the protestors rather than for legitimate public safety reasons.

judgment handed down today from the house of lords on Art 5 right to liberty & the actions of the police in creating cordons in public demonstrations & holding demonstrators within those cordons.

this relates to the May Day protests in oxford circus back in 2001. the situation is not exactly comparable to the Climate camp demonstrations, because the protestors in the May Day case had not given the police prior warning of the demonstration, or co-operated with the police in any way

RULING AS FOLLOWS

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200809/ldjudgmt/jd090128/austin-1.htm

Lord Hope: "There is no suggestion that she herself [the appellant who brought the case] was involved in any violent acts or that she had any other intention than to engage in peaceful protest. Nevertheless she willingly took the risk of violence on the part of other demonstrators with whom she chose to be present, and her own conduct was unreasonable in joining with others to obstruct the highway."

"Any steps that are taken must be resorted to in good faith and must be proportionate to the situation which has made the measures necessary. This is essential to preserve the fundamental principle that anything that is done which affects a person’s right to liberty must not be arbitrary. If these requirements are met however it will be proper to conclude that measures of crowd control that are undertaken in the interests of the community will not infringe the article 5 rights of individual members of the crowd whose freedom of movement is restricted by them."

"In my opinion measures of crowd control will fall outside the area of [Art 5's] application, so long as they are not arbitrary. This means that they must be resorted to in good faith, that they must be proportionate and that they are enforced for no longer than is reasonably necessary."

Lord Scott: "The imposition by the police of the Oxford Circus cordon on the appellant, and many others, was done for the purposes of protecting the physical safety of the demonstrators, including the appellant, and of protecting the neighbourhood properties from the violence that it was justifiably feared some of the demonstrators would perpetrate, violence that the appellant herself regarded as likely to happen. The intention of the police was to maintain the cordon only so long as was reasonably thought necessary to achieve those purposes and it is accepted by the appellant that the cordon was not maintained longer than was necessary to achieve those purposes. In the circumstances the confinement and restriction of movement that the cordon inevitably imposed on those within it did not, in my opinion, constitute an Article 5 deprivation of their liberty."

"I conclude that it is essential, in the present case, to pose the simple question: what were the police doing at Oxford Circus on 1 May 2001? What were they about? The answer is, as Lord Hope has explained in his full summary of the judge’s unchallenged findings, that they were engaged in an unusually difficult exercise in crowd control, in order to avoid personal injuries and damage to property. The senior officers conducting the operations were determined to avoid a fatality such as occurred in Red Lion Square on 15 June 1974 [see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Lion_Square_disorders]. The aim of the police was to disperse the crowd, and the fact that the achievement of that aim took much longer than they expected was due to circumstances beyond their control."

Lord Neuberger: "where, as happened to the appellant in this case, a person is confined in an area against her will by the police for well over six hours, in circumstances where paras (b) and (c) do not apply, the notion that there has been no infringement of article 5 seems, at least on the face of it, surprising. All the more so, given that the appellant was required to remain, in circumstances of some discomfort, in an area of some 2,000 square metres, cordoned in together with apparently some 3,000 other people, and where the confinement was in the context of the appellant exercising her undoubted right to demonstrate."

But... "The police are under a duty to keep the peace when a riot is threatened, and to take reasonable steps to prevent serious public disorder, especially if it involves violence to individuals and property. Any sensible person living in a modern democracy would reasonably expect to be confined, or at least accept that it was proper that she could be confined, within a limited space by the police, in some circumstances. Thus, if a deranged or drunk person was on the loose with a gun in a building, the police would be entitled, indeed expected, to ensure that, possibly for many hours, members of the public were confined to where they were, even if it was in a pretty small room with a number of other people. Equally, where there are groups of supporters of opposing teams at a football match, the police routinely, and obviously properly, ensure that, in order to avoid violence and mayhem, the two groups are kept apart; this often involves confining one or both of the groups within a relatively small space for a not insignificant period. Or if there is an accident on a motorway, it is common, and again proper, for the police to require drivers and passengers to remain in their stationary motor vehicles, often for more than an hour or two. In all such cases, the police would be confining individuals for their own protection and to prevent violence to people or property.

So, too, as I see it, where there is a demonstration, particularly one attended by a justified expectation of substantial disorder and violence, the police must be expected, indeed sometimes required, to take steps to ensure that such disorder and violence do not occur, or, at least, are confined to a minimum. Such steps must often involve restraining the movement of the demonstrators, and sometimes of those members of the public unintentionally caught up in the demonstration. In some instances, that must involve people being confined to a relatively small space for some time.

In such cases, it seems to me unrealistic to contend that article 5 can come into play at all, provided, and it is a very important proviso, that the actions of the police are proportionate and reasonable, and any confinement is restricted to a reasonable minimum, as to discomfort and as to time, as is necessary for the relevant purpose, namely the prevention of serious public disorder and violence. "

"anyone on the streets, particularly on a demonstration with a well-known risk of serious violence, must be taken to be consenting to the possibility of being confined by the police, if it is a reasonable and proportionate way of preventing serious public disorder and violence"

Ends

- The key bit here from the researcher on the application of this ruling to recent protests:

If it transpired, for instance, that the police had maintained the cordon, beyond the time necessary for crowd control, in order to punish, or “to teach a lesson” to, the demonstrators within the cordon, then it seems to me that very different considerations would arise. In such circumstances, I would have thought that there would have been a powerful argument for saying that the maintenance of the cordon did amount to a detention within the meaning of article 5."